Lots of additional commentary added only on the audio. I go into #FilmStack more (like 37 mins in I think). Lots on current World Series. Lots on the NBA gambling scandal. I add and update everything below, but here it is just pasted from the original article. The audio, to be clear, adds a ton. Sorry you have to listen to my nasally Jewy Fall clogged voice.
-
Second long read of week at end, on NBA, ESPN, and marketing in general. Read yesterday’s piece if you haven’t already, probably the main event of the week. Al Jazeera announced the name of the killer of Hind Rajab, and it’s Sean Glass, so death threats and wild conversations followed. And a four bags of popcorn movie…it’s truly a bottomless pit out there folks, be vigilant!
-
NBA gambling scandal dropped as I was finishing the piece I share below as long read for today. It’s so crazily symptomatic of our times. I don’t even really see it as a gambling issue, but more related to our wider compromises and misalignments. It’s what allows gambling in that’s worth exploring. The actual gambling is very cut and dry. People asking why the guy making $350k per game is risking it gambling, that’s not at all the question to ask. Why did we integrate gambling into sports in the first place? Where do opinions come from in general? Where is our attention spent? I refer to the idea that a great deal of sports reporting right now is funded by and centralized around gambling. If you removed gambling from sports, podcasts go with it. People have compared baseball’s immediate removal of Emmanuel Clase from the game upon his scandal, vs the news that NBA conducted their investigation on Terry Rozier, but ‘lacked investigative power’ to do anything about it. But the FBI did. The NBA flagged Rozier long before they had a Kash Patel + Donald Trump problem. Why didn’t they get rid of it like baseball did? Because baseball hasn’t milked itself as much as NBA, and it’s a less costly decision for them to admit a flaw, take the L and move on. The NBA is so leveraged into this stuff, and so good at it, that for them to step back even slightly, costs billions. The razor’s edge they run on gives no margin for error, and it’s billions at stake. They want it. They’re complaining today that it’s a plot, a conspiracy, Trump getting revenge against black people and wokeness and whatever else. So why didn’t they protect against this? Because it’s worth it for them not to. They want want want. That’s our world. Wanting. Baseball’s not innocent, just not as good at it. Mediocre World Series tix are $1000+. Why? Because someone will pay that. There are no things in our world anymore that just stay where they should be. Everything scales until it breaks. Someone will dump private capital in and demand growth eventually, and ride it until it breaks. Will this break the NBA? Hell no. Not even close. But it is worth examining. Same thing as Marvel. Why didn’t Marvel just do what it knew it needed to do right away? Why did it waste 7 years? Because someone was pushing it to the max until it broke.
Same goes for the guy on Instagram who threatened me for not posting “Free Palestine.” He knew I wasn’t the IDF soldier, he knew I was just some random guy with the same name. But he still tried to leverage the threat over me to get what he wanted. Why? Because he could. Because he’s not thinking about balance, not seeking some ideal of harmony. He has an ambition, and wants it in every form possible, as entire and scaled as possible.
We live in a world where corporations set us up against each other, in gladiatorial frameworks that max everything out. It’s ugly stuff. Doesn’t mean it has to dictate anything for us. I’m fine, the death threats stopped yesterday. I can laugh about it now. I’ll have a nice shabbat. Life goes on. BH. I think the key is about remaining vigilant. Recognize what’s going on. Don’t accept the menu They put in front of you. Unless that’s what you’re hungry for. Be prepared to ask them for an adjustment if you want it. Go somewhere else. Cook yourself. I feel like we’ve been lulled into some sense that there are options laid before us, and we must follow within their parameters. That’s not the world. Ignore these people. That’s what I talk about regarding ESPN. You don’t need to consider Stephen A. Smith’s opinions just because a corporation puts him on TV. You also don’t need to argue with anyone about Donald Trump’s manipulative insanity. Reposition yourself. Build structure for yourself to insulate fro these villains. Get closer to your people, the ones you align with, build things, and live the life you want to live.
ESPN, #FILMSTACK, ETC.
On what’s valuable to us in criticism and commentary, in sports and movies. On ESPN, #FilmStack and the actually great important voices we should give our attention to…
UPDATE: I’m adding this here after I wrote the rest of the piece already, because so much has happened since. First of all, I want to say, opening night NBA was incredible. Double OT defending champs beating new KD team with MVP hitting in the clutch…what more can we ask for as a civilization? Incredible basketball. Then NYK going from rumoring four starters benched to putting five guys in double figures in a resounding win against the team we got so much criticism for not beating last year. And Wemby Wemby Wemby. WOAH. WOW. It was all looking like…uh…NBA is absolutely back and ready to crush culture.
Then…a mafioso gambling scandal hits?!!?! WTF?!?! Anyway…I’m not gonna make the piece about this. But That did happen since I wrote the following. It doesn’t change anything, but it is symptomatic, in one direction or the other depending on how you look at it. The to-be-mentioned Ethan Strauss calls what I describe below ‘fracking the pie’, when NBA opened itself up to gambling, when they realized they needed to increase revenue, and it was easier to extract more value from the current fans than to acquire new fans. SO…legalize gambling. That’s in line with all I describe below. Less and shi*ttier product, more cost and friction. Less signal, more noise. More squeeze, less juice. More sh*t, cat just getting a year older. Etc. Below is the original piece.
NBA on NBC returned. People are praising the intro video. I dug it. It didn’t move me how it has apparently moved many others, but it’s solid. I think there’s this phenomenon of praise and analysis to marketing, as if we’re all reading the pitch decks and tipping our caps to the agency creatives or something who we of course know. This Substack linked below talked about it well. The video was fine, I don’t know, who cares? I do recognize there is art and tremendous craft to advertising, but we’ve gone far overboard.
I generally agree with both of these pieces, but I find myself alienated from the second one, which surprised me because I find Ethan Strauss as grounded as it gets and I tend to agree with him. Lemme be clear, I don’t disagree with him. But he seems further down the road than I’d expect.
TL;DR ESPN pushes narratives and random personalities over actual sports. Sports are the topic, but the kinetic energy and friction is the product. The first guy talks about how we’re not really sharing understanding, but rather positioning the world in a certain way constantly, and what kind of world do we live in if everyone is considering chess moves? We need some actual raw material, some uncontextualized ideas to think about. I think ESPN sucks, and I think it’s really weird when we give so much attention to advertising or glorify news commentators.
In context of NBA on NBC, and Strauss’ critique of ESPN pushing personalities and narratives over sports, someone asked me what I thought of Ernie, Chuck, Shaq and Kenny on ESPN. Did the brand new TNT-expats fall under my critique? Absolutely not.
My position is that I actually like sports. I played sports my whole youth, through my 20s, and continue to attend and sit in the same seats I grew up sitting in, next to the same family members I grew up watching with. It’s like synagogue for me. It’s very important. I got mild enjoyment as a kid when the NBA and NFL drafts began being covered, and when trades became more of a thing, but it never compared with just going to games. I have never wanted for more than just enjoying the sports. I love watching Knicks and Yankees, and lots of other sports. We can kiiiiinda talk about it, but I honestly don’t care much to. I’ve always been like the silent internalized dad type when it comes to sports. Yep. That was awesome. High five. Next. I never cared to debate nor analyze nor rank. I never hated other teams unless I hated them as people. Like I’m not anti-Toronto Blue Jays just because they beat us. I want them to win because it reflects well on us, if we only lost to the strongest. Astros I hate because they cheated. Dodgers I have simmering negativity toward because the capitalist hacks are over the top, and I also believe Ohtani is evil and being covered up for. But I also revel in his excellence and love seeing it. It’s more of a fun conspiracy theory of mine that everything we’ve ever heard about him is true, and he is just so excellent at baseball and so many people make money off of him, that all of his darkness gets covered up. It’s also justified as a net positive for the world so people can look up to him and not think he’s a degenerate gambler probably weird kink sexual deviant user and like I don’t know bank robber maybe?
I do not like that I live in a timeline now where I know who Stephen A. Smith and Pat McAfee are. I do not care about these people much less what their opinions are. I do not like listening to people more proportionate to the volume of their voice. I like quiet consideration and brief summations. I already feel myself to be the worst of this, and I respect people much more who can be concise and measured. I am rarely this, and I am ashamed. I cannot stand the Fox News-ification of ESPN. I loved PTI when it started and I still watched these things because it was two extremely capable, respectful, and established experts, for the first and only time so far, debating very serious topics, with seriousness, and a little humor. The guys were awesome. I liked Around the Horn too, but less, because the featured guests were not quite as excellent at Michael Wilbon and Tony Kornheiser. That’s it. That was more than enough. I loved all the Sportscenter people who just presented us with the info we wanted, in a fun and engaging way. But it only mattered because the info mattered. I liked Bob Ley’s Outside the Lines, and eventually 30 for 30 less, when it approached a topic I cared about. I did not watch those unless I already cared about the topic.
I tune into sports because I like sports. I like it exactly as much as I want to and no more no less. I grew up entirely satisfied with the role sports had in my life. And many like me agreed.
So why did it need to become more? Disney basically. Capitalism. Valuations and whatnot. They needed more of my attention, and more customers than just me. I wasn’t enough, and they didn’t have enough of me. So they stretched a trade conversation into a months-long narrative. They stretched maybe one important trade a year worthy of significant attention, into every single transaction being eventized. They couldn’t just have Mike and Tony give good thoughtful opinions, they needed opinions to be louder and more outlandish, worthy of the vibrancy of their presentation, the audacity of the claims, being repeated and shared on social media. Stephen A. Smith doesn’t present opinions, he considers how he can do a thing to get the most attention. What do you think about LeBron James? SAS hears How can I use people’s affinity for LeBron to make them need to tell other people who I think of him? So he says something ridiculous, and says it as loud as he can. This is all nonsense. Insulting. Pathetic.
Chuck, Kenny, and Shaq were all great basketball players. They also had personalities that bounced off the court, that we all happily followed. They’re as prestigious as it gets in the NBA world as players, and they’re all really funny cool insightful guys. I’d happily tune in for their specific special thoughts on the game. For like 10 minutes. Not for an hour. But 2-10 minutes, sure. And Ernie is one of the best sports commentators of all time, who wrangles these weirdos together. The unit is excellent. All time great unit. And for that, I want 2-10 minutes of them at a time, maybe once a week, and a few more doses during playoffs.
I do not want to be reminded SAS and McAfee exist! I do not care! They are enemies to my mind and focus. It’s like we’re having Shabbat dinner with family and friends we love, and there’s these other random people we have to consistently deny entry to. I don’t even want to think about this. We’re having dinner with friends and family, it’s not some profound decision to not allow strangers. We’re just being normal. ESPN’s sports coverage is like a weirdo trying to get involved in your personal life. Why do I need a profound reason to explain why I do not want to think about SAS and McAfee? They never established themselves as relevant to me. They have no reason to be in our lives. McAfee is even more Trumpian and destructive because he used the most toxic football player I can think of, Aaron Rodgers, whom I hated long before he abused the poor sickly vulnerable NY Jets. McAfee did a deal with Rodgers to make his podcast or YouTube show whatever relevant, and that’s how he rose to attention. It’s all junk. All pathetic. A random dude I don’t care about used the fame of a guy I hate to become the leading figure on a network I used to enjoy. Why do I need to critique this? It was imposed upon us. A nonsensical contrived manipulative system that clearly benefits a corporation over its customer (me). So I stopped paying attention a long time ago.
Lemme be clear again, nobody’s asking me what I think of these people. I just mean in the hypothetical debate. I reference all of this because I think Strauss gives far too much credence to these people. Strauss is a real legit worthy of respect sports reporter who broke a significant story through putting thousands of hours in paying attention and forming relationships, whereupon he grew to understand an aspect of Steph Curry’s and the Golden State Warriors’ success that explained it for everyone in a meaningful and powerful way. He wrote one of the most important sports analyses ever. He’s worth of our ear in a way SAS and McAfee are not. He’s valuable and to be respected. But in this case, I think he’s giving far too much credit to people who don’t deserve it. Strauss earned that, these guys never did. Strauss sat quietly and analyzed, spent hours on weird sleeping schedules to make sure the players and coaches and team administrators felt more comfortable with him. He showed up. SAS yelled and wore more expensive suits. These were their opposing strategies to make a living. Strauss has a relatively successful Substack, but SAS makes tens of millions from the worldwide leader and enjoys denying rumors he’s interested in running for President. FOL. I wish Strauss did not have to pay so much respect to these grifters and hustlers.
It should be easy and clear why I like Ernie, Chuck, Kenny and Shaq, but do not like SAS + McAfee. It’s the combo of these two articles linked above that generates the confusion. Why are hustlers in the same conversation as real legit people who do work? Marketing is not a thing. Marketing is taking the a value worth of 6 and turning it into value worthy of an 8. That’s villainous mostly. In a perfect world, a world that serves society and the people, there is no marketing. People just get more of the good things. You make the best bread, people buy it. You need not inflate its value by advertising.
A perfect sports world, likewise, would be effective presentations of the games, with brief commentary from a few experts. In baseball, we have the very special and historically relevant and charged trio of Jeter, A-Rod and Big Papi. Those three guys getting along and talking is incredible. They’re also notably three of the greatest living former players, and wildly charismatic and fun to watch. They each present distinct roles too…Jeter is the soft spoken but carry a big stick type who deals one sentence daggers that end up triumphing beyond anyone else’s thoughts. He distills the most profound ideas into actual sentences, where it takes you a second after to realize he just transcended anything you could have spent time attempting to understand. A-Rod is a brilliant analyst of the technical aspects of the game, and speaks in a not quite verbose manner breaking down complex aspects of baseball in a way everyone understands. Papi simplifies it and makes it more emotional. He takes A-Rod’s 3 minute explanation and turns it into a sentence, but unlike Jeter whose stoicism often borders on morbidity (I love this, not a critique haha), Papi’s sentence is one we laugh with. This is perfect. And we get them for 2-10 minutes at a time. That’s it. Otherwise, just give us the games. And tell us about the trades here and there. Anything beyond that is corporate malfeasance and should be ignored.
It’s actually just like Substack and the film world. Why do we care what all these random Substackers think of anything? They don’t write anything meaningful, they just weigh in on their weekly opinions to create content, and they use marketing to elevate their unnecessary opinions. Their opinions are rarely material, but simply yes/no good/bad for/against. They don’t make you think nor understand more. When they need to provide more words, they retread topics you can already find elsewhere. #FilmStack is ESPN. Don’t get me started on whatever Letterboxd is, which I’ve barely ever been on.
In contrast to the Jeter, A-Rod and Papi show I described, ESPN is the mundane opinions of effectively random individuals elevated to prominence by an authority I do not respect. ESPN does not get to decide to make me care about the opinion of whomever random losers they decide to put on their filler shows. I care what Chuck, Kenny and Shaq think, like I care what A-Rod, Jeter and Papi think…because I respect these people, as they established themselves by winning championships and providing deep insight into their experience throughout (Chuck exclusively the latter 🤣). I care what special people think. I do not care what any random thinks.
To correlate to movies, this is not to say that I only care what other directors think of films. I had the honor of sitting with Richard Brody at Nadav Lapid’s screening the other day. I care what Richard Brody thinks just like I care what Ethan Strauss thinks.
Brody completed what’s now my triptych of front row cinema experiences with legends I bow down to. I tell the story all of getting one of the last seats available at a screening in Venice, front row center, and chatting with the nice man next to me before and after the movie, only to realize it was David Bordwell, the man who wrote my film textbooks, whom you’d know from Observations on Film Art on Criterion. Another time I went to opening afternoon of Lady Bird and the only other two people in the theater were Emma Thomas and Christopher Nolan, seated a few rows in front of me, front row center. I told Brody those stories, and also related that it makes me feel like we have a private commune with the film. Brody talked about loving sitting in the front row not because of the privacy, but for the imagery. That when you make it so big, it’s effusive, and like there can be multiple frames. He revels in moving his head around, which I did notice when the film played. I’ve seen lots of movies with Richard Brody (he said he recognized me from screenings at LC, which made me kinda giddy), but I’d never talked to him. So I was nervously humbly admiring in my hello to him, but he was entirely disarming and warm and genuinely interested in what I had to say and felt. That’s probably why he’s who he is and got to where he is. I reference all of this to say I do bow down to critics and commentators. I read and deeply consider what Ethan Strauss thinks of politics actually because I respect his point of view on sports so much. ESPN is not structurally wrong. It’s effectively wrong. I would watch if they put Ethan Strauss on actually. They don’t. They choose Pat McAfee. Same goes with politics. I do care about politics. I just do not care about clowns. This will go on forever if I analyze the NYC mayoral debates, but I said the same thing this week. Why would I watch a bunch of a$$holes? I don’t like any of these guys (well, I love Curtis Sliwa actually, just not as mayor). I consider all of these candidates villains (Sliwa only in the context of choosing to stay in the race, otherwise he’s a hero in my eyes). Why would I want to watch them talk sh*t at each other for an hour? Who cares? Whether they will grow in influence or not, doesn’t mean I need to watch this nonsense. The debates are an ESPN / Fox News style TV show. DEBATES ARE CONTENT. Same as Charlie Kirk. Content. Strategy. Positioning. All this stuff manipulates us to make money on something unrelated to us. Understand it and live your life. Make sure you give your attention to those worthy of it, those considerate, those who provide value back. Sitting next to Richard Brody provided me with a more engrossing experience watching the movie I watched next to him, because he’s insightful and considerate. He’s amazing. His 50 or so years of film writing have given us endless intelligence to meditate on. Give people like Richard Brody attention. Who tf cares what random Substackers who use growth hack tactics to get clicks think of OBAA?
Who gives af who the criminal endorses???
For the full embodiment of everything I said in real life sports translation, look at Cooper Flagg’s face looking at Wemby in these clips: That is ESPN vs actual sports.
Also please get rid of gambling in sports!!! (ha this came out as I was finishing the piece)
SAS says it’s a Trump conspiracy I actually think he’s absolutely right in this case.















